587 Yonge Street, Toronto
There's cosy, then there's cramped! Granted, it's not meant for large groups, but they certainly have a small bar considering 50% of its name is BAR. I do love the variety of beers though, although it's not too enjoyable drinking standing up crammed between the bar and a few stools.
The staff could be nicer to groups of two or more, but what do I know about customer service.
They serve Rahier pastries, which I'm personally not a fan of, but others may disagree but eh, c'est la vie!
Also, two words, website-overhaul, please. Okay, three words.